Myth vs. fact: Credit card swipe fees
)
The National Retail Federation supports the Credit Card Competition Act to give retailers more choice over how credit card transactions are processed. The legislation would introduce competing networks, encouraging competition on fees, security and service.
Pass the Credit Card Competition Act
As Americans focus on affordability, hidden swipe fees continue to drive up the price of everyday purchases. Learn more.
The CCCA is gaining momentum in Congress as more businesses and consumers become aware of how rising credit card swipe fees impact the affordability of everyday goods and services. To combat growing support for the CCCA, the bank and network giants have spent a reported $200 million to lobby against swipe fee reform.
Although Wall Street has the funds, Main Street has the facts. Many of the banking industry’s arguments against the bill are misleading or untrue. To set the record straight, here are key claims against the Credit Card Competition Act and the truth behind them.
Myth: Merchants will pocket savings instead of using them to benefit consumers.
Fact:
Lower processing costs would give retailers more room to compete on price and invest in their businesses.
The retail industry is one of the most competitive sectors in the American economy. Retailers are constantly trying to offer customers the lowest prices to encourage sales. Savings are often shared with consumers and reinvested into the business.
When it comes to routing reform, history has shown this to be the case. After debit card swipe fee reform was enacted in 2011, analysis shows that debit swipe fee savings were used to shield consumers from higher prices that would have resulted from increases in other operating costs, such as transportation and fuel costs.
Wholesale prices for retail merchandise as measured by the Producer Price Index rose 9.4% from the time debit card reform went into effect through the end of 2016, while prices for consumers, reflected in the Consumer Price Index, increased only 4.3%. That is a significant gap between the higher costs merchants had to pay for the goods they sold and the prices they charged consumers. Consumer prices went up only half as much as wholesale prices, thanks in part to the savings from debit card swipe fee reform. Retail profit margins during this time painted a similar picture, with little to no growth following debit card reform.
Economic analysis has made it clear that savings from debit reform has consistently been passed along from merchants to consumers in the form of prices that are meaningfully lower than what consumers would have paid in the absence of those reforms.
Myth: The Credit Card Competition Act is a big-box bailout that won’t help small businesses.
Fact:
Small businesses stand to be the biggest beneficiaries of swipe fee reform. Visa and Mastercard set higher swipe fee rates for small businesses compared with larger competitors due to their lower transaction volume, putting smaller players at a competitive disadvantage. The National Retail Federation has documented small retailers’ concerns about high, nonnegotiable swipe fees. For these businesses, processing costs can limit hiring, expansion and investment.
Swipe fee reform would help level the playing field by enabling small businesses to seek lower rates and agreements that work best for their business. That would encourage networks to compete for retailers’ business, rather than leave merchants with fees they can’t negotiate.
Contact Congress
Tell Congress to support the Credit Card Competition Act.
Myth: Credit card rewards will disappear if the Credit Card Competition Act passes.
Fact:
Rewards are offered by card-issuing banks. NRF disputes the claim that routing competition would end them.
Card-issuing banks use rewards programs as a primary tool to attract and retain customers. Card rewards are among the most effective ways to incentivize card usage, build customer loyalty and increase transaction volume. Premium rewards cards also drive revenue for issuers with annual card fees, high interest rates and swipe fee rates as high as 4% of the transaction total.
Opponents of the CCCA argue that programs consumers now expect from issuers would be in jeopardy if credit card reform is passed. However, given the importance of these programs to issuers’ marketing and revenue goals, that logic does not track.
The card industry claims high swipe fees are needed to support credit card rewards. But credit card reform has taken place in other markets, such as those in Europe and Australia, and credit card rewards still exist even though swipe fee rates are a fraction of what U.S. merchants must pay. In the United States, the latest data shows that banks paid out $47.5 billion in rewards to cardholders in 2024 while collecting $187.2 billion in swipe fees that year, leaving them approximately $140 billion in profits from swipe fees on top of other revenue streams from annual card fees, late fees and interest payments. That means they would have plenty of money left to pay for rewards even if swipe fees were reduced.
Further driving this point home is the fact that most retailers offer rewards and loyalty programs of their own while operating on 2% to 3% profit margins. Bank profit margins are the highest of any industry at around 30% while profits for Visa and Mastercard are around 50%.
Competition in credit card routing under the CCCA would save American merchants and their customers an estimated $17 billion annually. While significant for merchants, the estimated savings pales in comparison with the nearly $200 billion in swipe fees they currently pay to banks and card networks per year.
Myth: The Credit Card Competition Act would open payment processing to unproven networks.
Fact:
Alternative networks already process billions of debit card and ATM transactions.
The CCCA would make credit cards more secure than they are today. In fact, debit networks have been shown to be more secure than Visa and Mastercard, with the network giants having eight times the fraud rate of independent debit networks, according to the Federal Reserve. Increased competition is expected to produce more innovation that will also lead to improved security.
Underscoring the need for improved security technology and innovation is the fact that the U.S. leads in the world in credit card fraud, accounting for 42% of fraud even though we only account for 26% of the world’s transaction volume. The absence of competition combined with fraud liability often falling on the merchant due to card network rules leaves little incentive for Visa and Mastercard to address their security issues.
The truth about the Credit Card Competition Act
The debate over the Credit Card Competition Act is really about whether the largest banks and card networks should have to compete for retailers’ business. The bill would give retailers more choice over how transactions are processed and encourage networks to compete on price, security and service. Small businesses stand to benefit from relief from high, nonnegotiable swipe fees that drive up costs and consumer prices. Banks and card networks should compete for business just like retailers do every day.





