Economy

Reframing the debate on the K-shaped economy

Retail Economic Perspective: Whether we are in a “K-shaped” economy driven mainly by high-income spending depends on the lens through which you view the consumer
November 18, 2026
A woman shopping.

Monthly Retail Sales

CNBC/NRF Retail Monitor, powered by Affinity Solutions, is a monthly measure of retail sales.

Retailer bottom line: Whether there is a “K shape” to consumer spending depends on your perspective. Some sectors of retail have a prominent K shape, while others have almost none. Ultimately, the letter we attach to the economy should not become more important than understanding the behavior behind the data. 

Few economic narratives have generated as much debate recently as the idea of the “K-shaped” consumer. The concept is straightforward: Higher-income households are spending strongly while lower-income households face greater pressure, resulting in an economy whose growth is dependent primarily on high-income earners. But there is a problem with this otherwise compelling story: The data does not always agree. 

What does recent Fed data say about the “K-shaped economy?” 

Federal Reserve data on household spending growth expectations currently shows little evidence of a K shape. Spending growth expectations among households earning less than $50,000 are running at least as strongly as those among households earning more than $100,000. Additionally, while net worth has grown most among the top 20% of households, the bottom 80% has seen steady growth as well.

Looking at a range of other sources, however, a much clearer divergence emerges. So which picture is correct? There is a good case that both are. 

Do sectoral considerations impact the K shape? 

Whether you see a K shape depends heavily on what spending you measure. Broad measures of household expenditures include necessities such as housing, utilities, gasoline and groceries alongside more discretionary purchases. Households have relatively little ability to stop paying the electric bill or buying food when their finances become strained. Discretionary purchases are different. Apparel can be postponed, restaurant visits can become less frequent and a planned upgrade can wait. That means financial pressure on lower-income households is likely to show up first, and most clearly, in discretionary spending rather than total spending. 

An analysis of spending by our partner Pyxis by Bain and Co., using credit and debit card data from Affinity Solutions, illustrates this distinction. In the first half of 2026, spending increased across almost the entire spending distribution. But the rate of growth differed markedly. Among the bottom 10% of spenders, staples spending declined 0.2% while discretionary spending increased just 0.2%. By the 70th-80th percentile, those figures had risen to 1.5% and 3.5%, respectively, and discretionary spending among the top decile increased even faster. 

The result looks considerably more K-shaped for discretionary spending than it does for staples. That matters enormously for retailers because higher-spending households also account for a disproportionately large share of expenditures in many discretionary categories. 

Does timing impact the presence of a K shape?  

Another issue is time. A K shape is not a permanent characteristic of the economy, and the answer can change depending on the beginning and ending dates chosen. 

Year-over-year comparisons can be particularly sensitive to base effects. A household group that spent unusually strongly or weakly a year earlier can produce a very different growth rate today even if its underlying financial circumstances have changed relatively little. Our first-half 2026 comparison, for example, measures January through June against the same months of 2025. Extend the comparison through the back-to-school and holiday periods, change the starting point or look over several years, and the apparent slope of the “K” can change. The letter we attach to the economy should not become more important than understanding the behavior behind the data. 

Are we all defining the ‘K’ in the same way?  

There is also a definitional problem. When some people hear “K-shaped economy,” they interpret the lower arm of the K literally, assuming that higher-income spending must be rising while lower-income spending is falling. That is not what our data shows today. Spending can grow among both higher- and lower-income households while still becoming more concentrated at the upper end because higher-income households are increasing their spending faster. In fact, one of the striking characteristics of the current consumer economy is that spending remains remarkably resilient across income distribution despite substantial differences in household financial circumstances. 

Explore NRF's monthly Retail Economic Perspectives.

For retailers, that distinction matters more than the debate over terminology. Retail sales have been strong because consumers across the economic spectrum continue to spend. The K-shaped story should not be interpreted as saying that lower-income consumers have disappeared or stopped contributing to growth. They have not. Rather, the composition and pace of spending increasingly depend on who the customer is and what the customer is buying. 

The economy may look less K-shaped when viewed through aggregate spending and considerably more K-shaped in discretionary categories. Both can be true at the same time.

Related Content